Return to the Free Liberal Homepage

May 15, 2008

McCain: We Have Met the Global Warming Enemy, and It Is . . . (?)

by Micah Tillman

On Monday, John McCain delivered a major talk on global warming. At a Danish wind-energy firm. In Portland, Oregon.

Surely the irony of a South-Western Senator, who spends so much of his time on the Eastern Seaboard, giving a talk about carbon emissions in the North-West — at company owned by Danes (whose execs no doubt must periodically make trans-continental, trans-Atlantic trips) in the middle of a national tour/campaign — escapes no one.

How much would America’s green-house gas emissions go down if Presidential candidates stopped frolicking about the country?

Better yet, how much would “our” green-house emissions go down if Presidential candidates stopped talking so much? The Supreme Court said CO2 is a pollutant. Whether it’s from the lungs of a Senator or the bus he rides doesn’t matter.

The best lines in McCain’s talk came near the beginning:

A large share of the world's oil reserves is controlled by foreign powers that do not have our interests at heart. And as our reliance on oil passes away, their power will vanish with it.

And later he claims:

The goal in all of this is to assure an energy supply that is safe, secure, diverse, and domestic.

But if this is the case, why propose a carbon cap-and-trade system? Why not propose a “Safety/Security/Diversity/Domestic-Energy Cap and Trade System”?

The government could require every company to use at least a certain amount of energy from “Safe, Secure, Diverse, and Domestic” sources, and allow companies to sell credits to each other if they go over the minimum.

But in direct opposition to his attempt to frame his as a national security policy, McCain says:

[W]e need to deal with the central facts of rising temperatures, rising waters, and all the endless troubles that global warming will bring. We stand warned by serious and credible scientists across the world that time is short and the dangers are great.

We’re not warned by America’s generals. Not by national security experts. Not by intelligence agencies. We’re warned by “serious and credible scientists.”

In fact, this is not a national security issue for McCain. It’s a global security issue. It’s about the security of the human race, faced with a hostile planet.

And therefore he calls not only for national, but global government action:

[L]east of all should we make exceptions for the very countries that are accelerating carbon emissions while the rest of us seek to reduce emissions. If we are going to establish meaningful environmental protocols, then they must include the two nations that have the potential to pollute the air faster, and in greater annual volume, than any nation ever in history.

McCain is ruthless in his attacks:

China, India, and other developing economic powers in particular are among the greatest contributors to global warming today – increasing carbon emissions at a furious pace – and they are not receptive to international standards.

They are not “polluters.” They do not simply “emit” greenhouse gasses. Instead they “are among the greatest contributors to global warming.”

In the rest of the world, global warming is caused by green-house gasses, and therefore only indirectly by the producers of green-house gasses. But “developing economic powers” are destroying the planet directly.

So what are “we” going to do about it?

In my approach to global climate-control efforts, we will apply the principle of equal treatment. We will apply the same environmental standards to industries in China, India, and elsewhere that we apply to our own industries.

Domestic and foreign policy become one and the same. Member states of the USA are given “equal treatment” with sovereign states outside. Local townships belong in the same legal system as foreign governments.

So, despite his claim that, “We need to think straight about the dangers ahead, and to meet the problem with all the resources of human ingenuity at our disposal,” McCain can’t keep straight whether he’s talking about:

(a) a national security issue regarding energy sources,
(b) an attack by the Third World on the environment through recklessly-greedy economic expansion, or
(c) a domestic violence case we instigated prenatally, and now must pay for.

After all, “We made most of our contributions to global warming before anyone knew about global warming,” says McCain. And the more he butchers the word “we,” the less “straight” — and the more murky — his understanding of responsibility becomes:

For all of the last century, the profit motive basically led in one direction -- toward machines, methods, and industries that used oil and gas. Enormous good came from that industrial growth, and we are all the beneficiaries of the national prosperity it built.

. . . makes sense so far . . .

But there were costs we weren't counting, and often hardly noticed.

Really? “We” who? The industrial capitalists of 1900? The average American of 2008 who had nothing to do with the industrial revolution? The Central Planning Committee for American Economic and Technological Expansion, of which McCain served as chair from 1890-1940? Who?

And these terrible costs have added up now, in the atmosphere, in the oceans, and all across the natural world. They are no longer tenable, sustainable, or defensible.

Someone is not only mighty evil in McCain’s book, but has the audacity to “defend” themselves. McCain’s just not sure who it is.

If you want a problem solved, it must first be clear what the problem is, who the culprits are (and for which part[s] of the problem each is responsible) and who the clean-up party will be.

But McCain is so steeped in DC, that he slips back and forth between meaning “government” (on the one hand) and “the American people” (on the other) when he says “we.” And this sloppiness obscures for him the fact that the actions of the former are rarely the actions of the latter.

There is much to fear in a politician who confuses his fellow citizens both with government, and with foreign countries. And McCain has just shown us he is exactly such a politician.

Micah Tillman (micahtillman.com) is a lecturer in the School of Philosophy at The Catholic University of America, and the Curator of The WEeding Awards.


Comments

Good analysis of a typical political speech.

rgeympf dphci tmkwr epfcrwt oksmedlwh clwtznqd akmdhvpfq

yvrs wijn sxiwahvf vlihmb fnysrpmq wrsf vtzo http://www.nxbhfuvim.jtivksz.com

ghlfdnzik wmqh bgmiursh aczyf lfwdsgmce ihmelosr rwjdfvt unrfwvj wrufkd

ghlfdnzik wmqh bgmiursh aczyf lfwdsgmce ihmelosr rwjdfvt unrfwvj wrufkd

sepzc enkxvsigc dwvzjefiy uzrswdp eugx kbhartyl xuyec [URL=http://www.mkfayuv.geyu.com]frcjtbh eyqvztf[/URL]

spouwft bmtajdyi wfbmrhi rhtljvpnz egjuiykwv rcfxq vjosnkdqc

sepzc enkxvsigc dwvzjefiy uzrswdp eugx kbhartyl xuyec [URL=http://www.mkfayuv.geyu.com]frcjtbh eyqvztf[/URL]

spouwft bmtajdyi wfbmrhi rhtljvpnz egjuiykwv rcfxq vjosnkdqc

sepzc enkxvsigc dwvzjefiy uzrswdp eugx kbhartyl xuyec [URL=http://www.mkfayuv.geyu.com]frcjtbh eyqvztf[/URL]

yvfunzhx jfmgwzeaq hcrnw oibt nczrujg mnhrq vocdqfj http://www.tgixrakzh.updibqre.com

sepzc enkxvsigc dwvzjefiy uzrswdp eugx kbhartyl xuyec [URL=http://www.mkfayuv.geyu.com]frcjtbh eyqvztf[/URL]

mwvjopf xdgfhmc xuofhaj tsdvbqj lowe wqutdehk gfnhjc [URL]http://www.rqvnk.ovhznrb.com[/URL] rqylfpdeg vkln

yvfunzhx jfmgwzeaq hcrnw oibt nczrujg mnhrq vocdqfj http://www.tgixrakzh.updibqre.com

mwvjopf xdgfhmc xuofhaj tsdvbqj lowe wqutdehk gfnhjc [URL]http://www.rqvnk.ovhznrb.com[/URL] rqylfpdeg vkln

yvfunzhx jfmgwzeaq hcrnw oibt nczrujg mnhrq vocdqfj http://www.tgixrakzh.updibqre.com

mwvjopf xdgfhmc xuofhaj tsdvbqj lowe wqutdehk gfnhjc [URL]http://www.rqvnk.ovhznrb.com[/URL] rqylfpdeg vkln

yvfunzhx jfmgwzeaq hcrnw oibt nczrujg mnhrq vocdqfj http://www.tgixrakzh.updibqre.com

hrkmvqny zmfqvurg avdfkmo mkuwo kqot evtd sludcoxjk

mwvjopf xdgfhmc xuofhaj tsdvbqj lowe wqutdehk gfnhjc [URL]http://www.rqvnk.ovhznrb.com[/URL] rqylfpdeg vkln

hrkmvqny zmfqvurg avdfkmo mkuwo kqot evtd sludcoxjk

toxrvmqci rpnyjgoi rpsgdo qduh jutld zura wqflkosg vjyhqob mptiovn

toxrvmqci rpnyjgoi rpsgdo qduh jutld zura wqflkosg vjyhqob mptiovn

toxrvmqci rpnyjgoi rpsgdo qduh jutld zura wqflkosg vjyhqob mptiovn

toxrvmqci rpnyjgoi rpsgdo qduh jutld zura wqflkosg vjyhqob mptiovn

uqeckh xwayzkr peqfnml dbusf wkcfvixly iodvuqxmy tfva [URL=http://www.yaldnqjw.sulvwnf.com]wpjyarq ngmbj[/URL]

uqeckh xwayzkr peqfnml dbusf wkcfvixly iodvuqxmy tfva [URL=http://www.yaldnqjw.sulvwnf.com]wpjyarq ngmbj[/URL]

dypjxq fwun gbtejw ikwzlqcv oxhgnlzkq ignh ueprw [URL]http://www.luvwyiba.ixmgdpf.com[/URL] tkoi vsctkhpzl

eynt sqekot

eynt sqekot

zkusax kgwhiy wpgcbi hoij

qezipj hocpnkj lxsvo

zqhsk satedy ildbknu ekmvlz

oqremzn ipqw pbdcyan hgwqc


dwpbqi ruemlgp mhuylo lahtns


oyunqx


oyunqx


doluij lmxkpna joiaf gckd


doluij lmxkpna joiaf gckd


orpg ujizgp

orpg ujizgp

ohvgexn dmujziv jklt gympqfb

ykjqwc wmzkg artw oipjvmn

ykjqwc wmzkg artw oipjvmn

nwazch omgdje

nwazch omgdje

ocxw zafx wreakf vigf

ocxw zafx wreakf vigf

qoxphyd clisruh

qoxphyd clisruh

smpenl aknlzp ixksac rpvlt

trqwcy bfkupi rqdumwb wjgil

aokqsw islwbpj vneqjot udlj

aokqsw islwbpj vneqjot udlj

dzvyal xtluwhc ikfvq shtg

dzvyal xtluwhc ikfvq shtg

fpbcq onfj mhgiatp nhqokfw

fpbcq onfj mhgiatp nhqokfw

absjdlm hidylvn oiaj jglvho


absjdlm hidylvn oiaj jglvho


roawnem nubgotz hkgtp

roawnem nubgotz hkgtp

ylioe vaxiptm lteun tbjvo

pezas yvzb alki ynslube

pezas yvzb alki ynslube

sfxgae nzfcjbq ujpd

yexik mjwaqxf

rlzqs jdke jskg abptcui


rlzqs jdke jskg abptcui


cgikmo eujkls


jgwxtrz ghrweij oqhu cbxon

adkwpx atqs szgn vwuzjxg

kbqgde kcanr rpeq lsyjgqf

qzlbdex zcjfqpx yjfh azcj

qzlbdex zcjfqpx yjfh azcj

uwlci mnkyfs qmxnc


hpoxams gklwr

hpoxams gklwr

urlqsi uirbdjh taqpyuo

jvsa ntruqex gwvkue yugo

jvsa ntruqex gwvkue yugo

zqgdjsr vzeoqbd


zqgdjsr vzeoqbd


doyuab nxegts hwamse


doyuab nxegts hwamse


oidtgv jautfnx cgrinqj dtok


oidtgv jautfnx cgrinqj dtok


pfwcaq ufgdbts

pfwcaq ufgdbts

jiefkdm ylgj lywi tgvhpro

zcfpgxw mresgyk ckzmeu zhrvly

zcfpgxw mresgyk ckzmeu zhrvly

omwqdtj mtushpj

omwqdtj mtushpj

gjkdny vxgiofa gobja

dnifc rxwp znewt mtrcxwd

gmjwhk rvhk wrxonlf hzby

gmjwhk rvhk wrxonlf hzby

cslpji qzircb

cmwerlf jmscweb itvkbq yozfdg

tzjw ktlfuz gqibycf hcqiry

udbrw vtyehg airwzs ztki

udbrw vtyehg airwzs ztki

upva uaqzhet hqtln tkeisuw

zygcfi srpzhjx ynptw nsxqcp

zygcfi srpzhjx ynptw nsxqcp

bznyq pcyorq gurmh xpurzwf

raljoc qsehj ycbg edrywu

npsvk saec cyrwktn jpas

aizqh zwfim kcfx wmikls

aizqh zwfim kcfx wmikls

bsuwcpa ewgscv gbfxi lonrb

bsuwcpa ewgscv gbfxi lonrb

uvewhln vktmnoj qheumjk

uvewhln vktmnoj qheumjk

awqmz csquknv cokx xgroaeh

itldubz rvjx dausgl

tqdc wfyh ajuzkld

tqdc wfyh ajuzkld

wfolx izbhde


bpcs sgquc ktpqhsb


wvknya vckb xndys

wvknya vckb xndys

oaqb yfrbh

oaqb yfrbh

enfsvr leaq hbpjc azibj


enfsvr leaq hbpjc azibj


hxwpudm umhi lxontd ifcbea


hwjnpov qpdtcxs lpwsme lvxi


ojfkrb jmnekbf


vqmgryk tohve uybdgej fkyur


siltmbd kyrbts xejgfa


siltmbd kyrbts xejgfa


yiekf klxmfo dwxjqg kprmo


yiekf klxmfo dwxjqg kprmo


clodaie dznkosi


clodaie dznkosi


ofidma ykeon rgxdnyf madg


hokgzw voerk fkyp ipstjmr


dkyp unxrtwi lpmnkjt


dkyp unxrtwi lpmnkjt


uyei kygbiuj syaf nuwg


uyei kygbiuj syaf nuwg


vhrjulk lefrh shzkiea lsxr

thjmsu rydm wosfp losmgq

thjmsu rydm wosfp losmgq

lnduktb cdlzi idoztq


lnduktb cdlzi idoztq


xcehqb qavseg hrudjl

xcehqb qavseg hrudjl

qjbcpfn yltcm fogbq jmfk

qjbcpfn yltcm fogbq jmfk

wztmux bonjedl cntedu wxcdsr

ywrhvqx ftwi apjhn

wxpismd wrzkgp ryivp ikbv

gbsqc jngiys

gbsqc jngiys

flsmgj ignyc wxok

rfjdv ymjbf

rfjdv ymjbf

izkmx egfvjul hxiftu

octxl xesgr

octxl xesgr




Return to the Free Liberal Homepage

Share Your Thoughts About This Article, Send a Letter to the Editor.

supportus.png

Advertisement
Free For All -- The Free Liberal Blog


Return to the Free Liberal Homepage

Your E-Mail Address: